The skeptical take first: most AR ROI calculators are lead-gen widgets with the vendor's 94% figure pre-loaded. Garbage in, gospel out.

What a useful calculator actually needs:
- Your baseline conversion rate and average order value, not industry averages. - Your return rate and per-return cost, because returns are half the AR value story. - Honest lift assumptions: model 20 to 40% of claimed vendor lifts, not the headline. - Asset costs: models per SKU times per-model price. At $9.99 per HD model, a 100-SKU test catalog costs $999. - Time horizon: AR assets depreciate slowly. Amortize over 24 months, not 6. Sources: Shopify Do the spreadsheet yourself in 20 minutes. It beats any calculator app because it uses your numbers. The calculators are useful for one thing: reminding you to include return-rate reduction, which most sellers forget and which is often the bigger win.